Scheel Letters: Resting Eggs
Courtesy of
ARK - Arizona Rivulin Keepers
The Scheel Letters, No. 17
Resting Eggs
In a previous letter you will find some thoughts on the oxygen problem in the question
of Resting Eggs. In order to find out if eggs might be kept for a long time under
non-oxygen conditions I collected eggs of several species and stored them in completely
water-filled ampoulles (the normal 2 ccm ones) and closed them with cork and parafin.
All eggs of Aphyosemion (calliurum, coeruleum, calabaricus, cognatum etc.) died
(turned yellowish and turbid) after one or more weeks. When opening the ampoulles
the water gave away a strong smell of H2S. But in some ampoulles containing eggs
from Cynolebias nigripinnis, C. bellotti, C. melanotaenia, the eggs did not change
and still were transparent and apparently alive.
In June my stock of ampoulles was used and one evening I opened two ampoulles
in order to use these for mailing of eggs. These ampoulles contained:
1) 5 eggs Cynopoecilus melanotaenia closed for 115 days.
2) 11 eggs cross C. ladigesi/melanotaenia closed for 75 days.
Water in ampoulles was perfectly clear. A certain smell of H2S was traced.
Parafin lock was unbroken. Now the 10 eggs C. ladigesi/melanotaenia all contain a
hatchable embryo (one egg developed an embryo when in ampoulle and this egg had a
dead embryo when I opened the ampoulle). The five eggs from Cyn . melanotaenia
still are transparent and possibly alive.
This small experiment might be of great importance in the future mailing
of eggs from "real annuals" as lots of eggs might be stored in very small containers
and without any air. Also possibly during wintertime such eggs might be mailed by
ordinary mail and then the risk of freezing the eggs will be much smaller when mailing
eggs overseas.
Possibly also the experiments might guide to a solution of the problem of
Resting Eggs in Killies. I certainly know that much more work must be done on this
problem before a solution comes into reach. Now I am more sure that the oxygen
concentration plays an important role in the development of this phase in eggs.
Resting Embryo
Unlike the case in the 1958 breeding of Nothobranchius melanospilus the
(about 50 only) eggs that now are stored on low water in cups do not develop normally
giving a hatchable fry after about 4 weeks. In most eggs the development of the
embryo stops at the phase "resting embryo" and stays in this phase for rather long
time. This is also the case in Notho. "kuhntae" (Griem's stock, possibly "orthonotus").
Here are some data.
Nothobranchius "kuhntae":
- two males and one female, very young. Spawning
until 20 Apr. 59, peat washed out, found 36 eggs. 15 closed up in a 2 ccm ampoulle,
airtight. 21 on low water for examination. Egg measured: yolk = about 1.025 mm,
egg about 1.20-1.25 mm. Egg oval. Yolk not quite regularly shaped. Eggs do not
adhere to peat, but catch each other, forming balls. Breeding pair died a few days
later. One egg in water got fungus. 8 more eggs were found when pair died.
- 04 May 59: 27 eggs on low water: all eggs have small transparent embryo.
- 30 May 59: 27 eggs on low water: two eggs have big embryo, near hatching point,
25 eggs unchanged since 04 May 59.
- 17 June 59: 10 eggs (most with transparent embryo)
mailed to Peter T.
- 06 July 59: one fry hatched (Belly slider), 3 eggs have hatchable
embryo, all other eggs seem to develop now.
- 28 May 59: "15-egg-ampoulle" opened. 12 eggs left, transparent, the 3 more
eggs are turbid, dead. Strong smell of H2S, water turbid. All eggs inspected, no
trace of an embryo.
- 30 May 59: one more egg died.
- 11 June 59: one egg has a small
and transparent embryo, 10 are without any trace of an embryo.
- 06 July 59: 4 eggs
have embryo with black eyes, blood circulation. 3 have small transparent embryo.
4 eggs have no embryo. "Griem's stock".
Nothobranchius melanospilus:
- (Henry Hansen's stock): two males and one female,
very young. Spawning until 13 May 59: peat washed. Found 62 eggs. All placed on
low water for examination.
- 30 May 59: 58 eggs left. Eggs vary greatly in size,
17 eggs are dead. 41 eggs are sound: 3 have no trace of an embryo, 31 have small
transparent embryo, 7 have pigmented embryo, growing.
- 11 June 59: 6 eggs have big
hatchable embryo, 32 eggs have small, transparent embryo, one egg has no embryo
(yolk ball deformed).
- 20 June 59: 13 ripe eggs dried up.
- 06 June 59: 21 eggs
have hatchable or nearly hatchable embryo, 2 eggs have small transparent embryo.
Pterolebias longipinnis: Development of Eggs. - Spawning 2 young males and
one young female on fine mud until 10 May 59: peat washed out. Found 84 eggs. 2
of these had big, pigmented embryo (possibly eggs which had been in the very upper
layer of the mud).
- 23 May 59: 11 eggs are ripe, dried up in little peat.
30 May 59: 6 eggs have no embryo or very small embryo (eggs adhere some small particles
of peat and are difficult to inspect). 54 eggs have pigmented embryo, not at the same
state of development.
- 15 June 59: water on small sample of peat, 11 sound fry hatched
after 24 hours (two hours after watering I saw at least two fry swimming normally).
36 eggs in water are ripe (15 have been mailed on 17 June 59, most of these had only
a very small embryo) and were dried up. Indeed the development in "longipinnis"
is much quicker than in "peruensis". Also eggs of "longipinnis" have another pattern
on membrane (fine dots). "peruensis" has small dots and large dots, not far from
the pattern in "whitei". You will always be able to distinguish eggs of the two
species of Pterolebias by the pattern on egg membrane, although eggs have equal
size. Pterolebias longipinnis is Foersch's stock. Pterolebias peruensis is J.
Scheidness' stock.
Cynolebias bellotti Guevara's stock. - 5 males and 13 females, all young,
spawning until 02 May 59: 617 eggs washed out. Many of these eggs were mailed,
so the results are not very exact indeed. Resting eggs mostly were mailed in order
to be sure that they arrived alive.
- 30 May 59: all eggs stay on shallow water.
293 had an embryo with black pigmentation, 192 had no trace of embryo. Eggs are
easily inspected, they do not adhere much peat.
- 09 June 59: eggs in plastic box
begin to hatch by themselves. As eggs, also fry have different size. Biggest are
6.0 mm, smallest about 4.5 mm. 7 fry have total. 12 June 59: 6 more fry hatch.
13 June 59: 6 more fry hatched.
- 14 June 59: 106 fry hatched by themselves.
- 17 June 59: 23 more fry,
- 18 June 59: 33 more fry, these fry have big yolk balls.
The 23 fry that hatched on 18 June 59 were placed in a small cup with only a few
millimeters of water in order to see if they were able to be normal swimming fry.
On 19 June, 17 of these 23 fry were normal swimming fry!!! As I had enough specimens
of this species, I placed all belly sliders and normal fry together in a two liter
glass. Now 07 July 59 only 3 fry are left, they measure 1.5-2 cm, all others were
eaten up or died. They did not get much food, as food was scarce. It is interesting
to see that the hatching of a few fry certainly ignites the hatching of most ripe
eggs present in water. Also I did not believe that "bellotti" hatched in water
were able to be normal fry.
